Editorial policy

Reviewer and action editor compensation policy

Last updated: 22 October 2026

Reviewers

Reviewers are paid on the basis of their contribution to the whole review process, including their initial report, follow-up discussion, any revision rounds, and, if selected, their authoring of the review summary.

The compensation includes incentives for quality, timeliness, and (if applicable) writing the review summary. The action editor judges quality and selects which reviewer will write the review summary.

Payment is independent of the final recommendation the reviewer makes for the paper.

Reviewer assessment criteria

The action editor judges a completed review engagement “outstanding” where it substantially improves the manuscript, or the reviewers’ collective understanding of it, e.g., by identifying a significant error, reframing what the paper actually establishes, or conducting additional analysis.

The editor should be able to give the reason in one sentence, which is recorded with the payment.

Action editors

Action editors are paid on the basis of their contribution to the whole review process, including desk review, recruitment of reviewers, review discussion moderation (including revision rounds), their decision proposal, and review summary moderation.

Payment is independent of the final decision the action editor proposes for the paper, although the opportunity for post-desk handling is unavoidably dependent on the desk decision.

Payment

Reviewers and Action editors choose whether to accept or waive the offer of compensation before beginning their work. All payments are settled at the close of the review process, i.e. following the acceptance, rejection, or withdrawal of the manuscript.

Reviewers and action editors who waive payment are given the opportunity to make a non-binding recommendation that the journal donates the same amount to a 501(c)(3) nonprofit they select. These donations, including the amount and recipient, are made at the sole discretion of the journal.

Eligibility

Senior editors or managing editors acting as reviewers or action editors are not eligible for payment.

Reviewer compensation rates

A completed review process earns the reviewer

  • $500 base rate,
  • plus $500 for a review of outstanding quality (judgment of the action editor),
  • plus $300 where the reviewer’s initial report arrives within 15 days of the initial invitation,
  • plus $400 for writing the review summary, if they are selected to do so.

Action editor compensation rates

A completed review process earns the action editor

  • $300 for a desk review, and
  • $800 for post-desk handling of the paper: reviewer recruitment, review discussion moderation, final decision proposal, and — if accepted — review summary moderation.